Home Today Tomorrow Weekend Week
Major League Soccer

New York City FC vs Columbus Crew Prediction

Major League Soccer 10.05.2026 · 20:30 Yankee Stadium Referee: Sergiy Boyko, Ukraine
New York City FC emblem
New York City FC
L
W
L
D
L
vs
– : –
10 May · 20:30
Columbus Crew emblem
Columbus Crew
L
W
W
W
L
Our Prediction
Total:Over: 2.5
Pre-match analysis
8 / 10
Odds
2.88

Win Probability

Pre-Match Analysis
10%
New York City FC
45%
Draw
45%
Columbus Crew

Form Comparison

■ New York City FC ■ Columbus Crew
New York City FC
Columbus Crew
13%
Form
88%
38%
Att
62%
39%
Def
61%
47%
Poisson distribution
53%
38%
H2h
62%
44%
Goals
56%
37%
Total
64%

Head-to-Head

Overall
Home
Away
17.09.2025
New York City FC vs Columbus Crew
3 — 2
22.03.2025
Columbus Crew vs New York City FC
0 — 0
31.08.2024
Columbus Crew vs New York City FC
4 — 2
17.08.2024
Columbus Crew vs New York City FC
1 — 1
14.06.2024
New York City FC vs Columbus Crew
2 — 3
08.07.2023
Columbus Crew vs New York City FC
1 — 1
17.06.2023
New York City FC vs Columbus Crew
1 — 1
06.08.2022
Columbus Crew vs New York City FC
3 — 2
14.05.2022
New York City FC vs Columbus Crew
2 — 0
30.07.2021
New York City FC vs Columbus Crew
4 — 1

Last Matches

New York City FC
Columbus Crew
03.05.2026
New York City FC vs DC United
0 — 2
29.04.2026
New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC
3 — 1
25.04.2026
CF Montreal vs New York City FC
0 — 1
22.04.2026
New York City FC vs FC Cincinnati
4 — 4
18.04.2026
New York City FC vs Charlotte
1 — 2
W: 1 · D: 1 · L: 3

As the Major League Soccer season unfolds, New York City FC and Columbus Crew prepare to face off at the iconic Yankee Stadium on May 10th. Both teams have shown contrasting form in recent weeks, making this matchup a fascinating contest for fans and analysts alike. With an array of attacking talent on display, the match promises plenty of action and potential drama.

New York City FC: Navigating Inconsistency

New York City FC comes into this fixture with a mixed bag of results. Despite a recent 3-1 victory over New York Red Bulls, their overall form has been inconsistent, highlighted by a thrilling 4-4 draw at home against FC Cincinnati. Their offensive prowess is evident, averaging 2.60 goals per game in their last five matches. However, defensive frailties have been a concern, conceding an average of 2.00 goals per game in the same period. At Yankee Stadium, NYCFC has struggled to maintain consistency, with a record of one win, two draws, and two losses in their last five home clashes. Fortunately for them, there are no injury or suspension concerns, allowing head coach Nick Cushing to field his strongest lineup.

Columbus Crew: Riding a Wave of Form

In contrast, Columbus Crew arrives in New York on a wave of positivity. Having won four out of their last five matches, including a commanding 4-1 victory against One Knoxville, they seem well-positioned to challenge NYCFC. With an average of 2.40 goals scored per match while conceding just 0.80, their form is driven by a balanced approach on both ends of the pitch. Their away performance has been solid, securing two wins and a draw in their last five road games. Like their opponents, Columbus Crew has a full squad available, with no players sidelined due to injury or suspension, offering head coach Wilfried Nancy the flexibility to adjust his tactics as needed.

Prediction: Goals on the Horizon

Given the recent form and goal-scoring records of both teams, this matchup promises to be an open affair with plenty of goalmouth action. While New York City FC has shown vulnerabilities at the back, their attacking intent cannot be underestimated. Columbus Crew, buoyed by their positive run, will look to exploit any defensive lapses. Historically, encounters between these two sides have been high-scoring, with the last five meetings featuring a total of 21 goals. The most likely scenario is a match with over 2.5 goals scored, reflecting both teams' attacking capabilities and defensive concerns. The combination of NYCFC's attacking flair and Columbus Crew's balanced approach makes this an intriguing contest, and fans can expect a high-energy affair at Yankee Stadium.

Prediction and Betting Tips

8/10 Confidence
Total:Over: 2.5

Both teams have been involved in high-scoring games recently, with NYCFC averaging 2.60 goals scored and 2.00 goals conceded, while Columbus Crew averages 2.40 goals scored and 0.80 goals conceded.

2.88
Odds
All: Both Teams to Score: Yes
75%
Total Team 1 Over: 1.5
65%
Total Team 2 Over: 1.5
60%
X2
55%

Bookmakers Odds Online

New York City FC vs Columbus Crew
Pin-UP
W12.40
X3.55
W22.70
William Hill
W12.38
X3.30
W22.70
Bet365
W12.20
X3.50
W23.00
Marathonbet
W12.39
X3.50
W22.72
Unibet
W12.28
X3.55
W22.95
Betfair
W12.30
X3.60
W22.80
BetVictor
W12.30
X3.40
W22.75
Pinnacle
W12.47
X3.61
W22.72
Betano
W12.47
X3.60
W22.72
Dafabet
W12.38
X3.60
W22.80

Major League Soccer Tournament Standings

#TeamMPWDLPts
1
San Jose Earthquakes logoSan Jose Earthquakes
11 9 1 1 28
2
Vancouver Whitecaps logoVancouver Whitecaps
10 8 1 1 25
3
Los Angeles FC logoLos Angeles FC
11 6 3 2 21
4
Seattle Sounders logoSeattle Sounders
9 6 2 1 20
5
Minnesota United FC logoMinnesota United FC
11 6 2 3 20
6
Real Salt Lake logoReal Salt Lake
10 6 1 3 19
7
FC Dallas logoFC Dallas
11 4 4 3 16
8
Houston Dynamo logoHouston Dynamo
10 5 0 5 15
9
Colorado Rapids logoColorado Rapids
11 4 1 6 13
10
Los Angeles Galaxy logoLos Angeles Galaxy
11 3 4 4 13
11
Austin logoAustin
11 3 4 4 13
12
San Diego logoSan Diego
11 3 3 5 12
13
Portland Timbers logoPortland Timbers
10 3 1 6 10
14
St. Louis City logoSt. Louis City
10 1 3 6 6
15
Sporting Kansas City logoSporting Kansas City
10 1 2 7 5
Recommended Match Predictions
Get Today's Best Predictions
AI-powered analysis across 50+ leagues. Free forever.
Start Now